Customer Story: The Same Problem Came Back. This Time, the Plumber Found Out Why.

Technician working on toilet

When a problem comes back, the first repair usually treated the symptom and left the cause. Kathy learned that when her toilet began smelling of sewer gas again, years after she thought it had been fixed.

Kathy’s toilet seal appeared to be failing again, letting sewer gas escape when the toilet was flushed. She had dealt with the same issue years earlier and was surprised to see it return.

What Kamil Found

Patrick Riley technician Kamil explained that the earlier repair had been a temporary patch rather than a fix. The cause was a rusted flange and a crooked, raised pipe beneath the toilet. Kamil and the team worked with Kathy to find a solution that corrected the cause while keeping the cost down.

“I trust Kamil and Patrick Riley to take care of my plumbing and HVAC issues and quote me fair pricing,” Kathy said.

A Second Issue, Caught During an Unrelated Visit

Kathy also wanted to replace a leaking ice maker line with a spigot for her dryer’s steam function. While preparing that estimate, Kamil found that the home’s water pressure was too high and that the pressure vacuum breaker serving the pool and irrigation system was failing. The whole job, from quote to completion, took two days, and Kamil explained each step as he went.

Why a Toilet Seal Fails Again

A toilet sits on a flange, the ring that anchors it to the floor and connects it to the drain pipe. A wax or rubber seal between the toilet and the flange keeps water and sewer gas inside the drain. If the flange is rusted or the pipe beneath it sits crooked or too high, the toilet cannot seat evenly, and the seal fails no matter how many times it is replaced. Fixing the seal alone buys time. Fixing the flange and the pipe stops the problem from returning.

Why High Water Pressure Matters

Water pressure above the normal range for a home wears out faucets, toilet fill valves, appliance hoses, and water heater fittings faster than they should. A pressure vacuum breaker is a safety device on an irrigation or pool line that keeps water from flowing backward into the home’s drinking water supply. When it fails, it can leak or allow that backflow. Catching both problems during an unrelated estimate saved Kathy a separate service call and the fixture damage that high pressure causes over time.

Why Finding the Cause Matters

Kathy’s experience shows the difference between a patch and a repair. A technician who looks beneath the symptom, whether that means finding a rusted flange behind a failed seal or a pressure problem during another job, saves the homeowner from dealing with the same issue again later.

If a Plumbing Problem Keeps Coming Back

If a plumbing problem returns after a repair, the cause was likely never addressed. Patrick Riley provides toilet repair and the full range of residential plumbing services for Phoenix-area homes, and the technician explains what was found and quotes the fix before starting. Contact Patrick Riley online or by phone to schedule a plumbing evaluation.


Have a question?

Let’s connect and have a quick conversation to see how we can help.

(928) 255-1040 Call Now

Recommended Reads:

Read All Blog Posts